Math review doesn’t have to feel like worksheet overload. Imagine your class solving cases (using place value, addition, subtraction, and problem-solving) to unlock clues and catch a culprit or uncover a lost treasure. That’s what 1st grade math mysteries do: they take rigorous first grade math standards and turn them into story-driven mysteries your students want to solve.
These mysteries work for test prep weeks, math centers, early finishers, small groups, sub plans, or whole class fun. Games feel purposeful because students must apply math skills to eliminate suspects, crack passwords, and piece together clues.
Math mysteries are narrative-based challenges where students read a storyline (like a missing pet or secret code) and then solve a series of problems to earn clues that help them solve the case. It’s logic plus math. This means deeper thinking and better retention.
Instead of drilling skills in isolation, kids use what they’ve learned to investigate, analyze, and justify answers that are all wrapped in a theme that keeps engagement high.
Here’s how they’re different from typical math review:
No more boring review pages. Students feel like detectives, and you get meaningful practice that builds confidence.
If you’re new to mystery-style escape rooms, the easiest way to understand them is to try one!
This free math and reading mystery lets you see the “magic of mysteries” in action — students solve clues, eliminate options, and arrive at one final answer.
And the coolest part? The math and reading mysteries have different culprits so you can play twice (once in each subject)!
You can use 1st grade math mysteries in a bunch of ways:
No matter how you use them, students stay focused because the stories give purpose to every problem.
Each math mystery you use can focus on specific 1st grade standards — whether it’s place value, number sense, addition, or subtraction. You choose the stories that match the skill you’re teaching or reviewing.
Math mysteries don’t replace core instruction, but they reinforce what students have already learned with purposeful practice that feels like play.
The Lifetime Learner’s math mysteries are designed to make first grade math review engaging without adding extra prep for teachers. Each mystery turns skill practice into a problem-solving experience where students solve clues, eliminate options, and work toward a final answer. The format stays consistent so students can focus on the math, while the themes and skills keep review fresh and motivating all year long.
• Print-and-go mystery worksheets
• Digital version in Google Slides
• 3-clue version and 5-clue version for easy differentiation
• Recording sheet for students to track clues
• Clear teacher directions
• Certificate of completion
• Fast finisher directed drawing activity
Math mysteries help with:
Plus, teachers tell me these work great the week before a test because students stay focused and excited about the content instead of zoning out.
Are you ready to try a math mystery in your 1st grade class, but you’re feeling stuck when it comes to finding a theme, skill, or standard you need? To make it easy to find a math mystery that fits your curriculum, I’ve put together 30 themed first grade math mysteries, each aligned to specific math skills.
Use the list below to jump to the type of math practice you’re looking for, or scroll through to see all of the themes included.
Jump to Frequently Asked Questions
Goal: Students figure out which pet their parents got for them as a surprise.
Click here for more information about the first grade pet math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out which fairy tale character’s house the missing princess is hiding at.
Click here for more information about the first grade fairy tale math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students try to figure out where the treasure chest was hidden.
Click here for more information about the first grade pirate math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out whose order is missing from the table at the restaurant.
Click here for more information about the first grade restaurant math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students figure out where around the school the missing trophy is hidden.
Click here for more information about the first grade sports math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to discover what is inside the mystery box.
Click here for more information about the first grade box math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students figure out where the cotton candy is hidden in this whodunnit.
Click here for more information about the first grade theme park math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students figure out which creature the scuba diver saw while he was under the sea.
Click here for more information about the first grade ocean math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students complete clues to find out what animal the safari jeep stumbled upon in the African savannah.
Click here for more information about the first grade safari math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students discover where the video game final boss is hiding in the video game world.
Click here for more information about the first grade video game math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to discover who won the big race.
Click here for more information about the first grade race car math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students crack the case of which dinosaur stole the dinosaur egg from the nest.
Click here for more information about the first grade dinosaur math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students head into outer space to find the planet the missing astronaut went to explore.
Click here for more information about the first grade outer space math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students embark on a journey of which magical creature took the magic wand.
Click here for more information about the first grade magic math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students attempt to figure out where they left their missing suitcase around the world.
Click here for more information about the first grade travel math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out where your friend is at summer camp.
Click here for more information about the first grade camping math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students embark on a journey to crack the case of where the mailman is around the town.
Click here for more information about the first grade mailman math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students complete a case to decipher which donut went missing at the bakery.
Click here for more information about the first grade donut math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students become detectives who are tracking down the zoo animal who got out at the zoo!
Click here for more information about the first grade zoo math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students figure out which instrument went missing at the rock concert.
Click here for more information about the first grade rock star math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out which student took the missing pencil.
Click here for more information about the first grade school-themed math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students figure out which Halloween character took the candy at the party.
Click here for more information about the first grade Halloween math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out which dish they need to bring to Thanksgiving dinner.
Click here for more information about the first grade Thanksgiving math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students crack a case where they need to find out where Santa is at the North Pole.
Click here for more information about the first grade Christmas math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students decipher clues to find out which snowman belongs to them!
Click here for more information about the first grade winter math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve a case to find out which house the Valentine’s Day party is being held at.
Click here for more information about the first grade Valentine math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students become detectives to find where the leprechaun is hiding in the leprechaun village.
Click here for more information about the first grade Saint Patrick’s Day math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students solve clues to figure out where the Easter bunny is hiding on the map.
Click here for more information about the first grade Easter math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students complete clues that get them closer to figuring out what food the deer keeps eating out of the garden.
Click here for more information about the first grade spring math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Goal: Students work through clues to uncover which kid at the beach took the missing sunglasses.
Click here for more information about the first grade summer math mystery on TPT.
Or grab it right here directly on the website.
Both! There are 2 versions so you can use the version that works best with your class. Or, you could differentiate and use the 3 clue version with some students and the 5 clue version with other groups. Both versions lead to the same conclusion/culprit, ensuring that students will not be aware of the different leveled assignments.
You can use this whole group, small group, in partners, table groups, independently, as homework, and more! Students in K-1 will need support reading the directions the first few times they complete these mysteries. I’d suggest completing them with teacher support in whole group or small groups for K-1. For grades 2-5, partners, table groups, and independent practice is appropriate. As students become more comfortable, working in pairs and independently will become more feasible.
No—phonics and grammar mysteries are completely different! They use their own set of clues, target grammar or phonics skills, and end with a unique conclusion. The only shared piece is the starting list of suspects, but each mystery reveals a different culprit. Check out the preview to see the differences in detail—you can absolutely purchase both and enjoy solving the mystery twice!
Yes! The digital version is available in Google Slides and the link is included in the printable PDF. You can download the Google Slides to use in PowerPoint if needed as well.
A fast finisher directed drawing activity is included for students who finish early! There is also a certificate of completion for every student. You could also have students work on incomplete assignments or read a book.
Looking for an easy way to increase student engagement? You’re in the right place! On the blog, you’ll discover practical tips for how to use mysteries in your classroom and the top mystery themes for K-5.
Find information on what you need:
Browse Mysteries on the Website Shop:
Join in on social media! Follow along to see more on Instagram, Facebook, Facebook Group, or TikTok.
